Why Your Follow-Up Strategy Is Failing You (And How to Fix It)

In partnership with

In B2B sales, follow-ups are both an art and a science. While some sales reps excel at engaging prospects quickly, others struggle with timing, frequency, and messaging. But what separates effective follow-ups from those that fail to convert?

There are many myths about follow-ups—how often to send them, what to say, and when to reach out. If you've been relying on gut instincts rather than data, you might be missing out on opportunities to close deals. This blog will explore the science behind follow-ups, dispelling common myths, and providing strategies backed by stats and research. Whether you're a seasoned sales pro or just starting out, this guide will challenge your assumptions and provide new tactics to master the follow-up process.

Myth 1: Follow Up Once and They’ll Reach Out When Ready

It's easy to think, "I sent the email, they'll respond when they're ready." Unfortunately, this myth can leave valuable deals on the table. In reality, 80% of sales require five or more follow-up calls after the initial contact, according to a study by Marketing Donut. Yet, 44% of salespeople give up after one follow-up. The truth is, reaching out once isn’t enough.

Following up more than once is critical because most decision-makers are busy. They may not respond right away, not because they’re uninterested, but because your email got lost in their inbox, or they had other priorities. Timing, persistence, and relevance are key factors in getting a response. Following up shows that you’re committed to helping them solve their problem, not just closing a deal.

Alternative Approach: Create a Follow-Up Cadence

To avoid falling into the "one-and-done" trap, create a follow-up cadence that spans several weeks or months. A good cadence starts with an initial email, followed by another in 3-4 days, then again after a week, and continues with regular touchpoints over time. The goal is to stay top of mind without being too aggressive.

Sales Technology: Tools like Outreach.io and SalesLoft can help you automate and manage this cadence, ensuring you stay consistent while allowing for customization at every step. These platforms offer insights on when and how often to follow up based on prospect behavior, helping to optimize the process.

Sales Techniques: Using a "3-touch method" is another effective cadence. Start with an introductory email, follow up with value-add content (e.g., a case study or industry trend), and end with a direct ask for a meeting or call. This structure balances persistence with professionalism, avoiding the trap of sounding repetitive.

Insider Tip: Personalize your cadence by adding a handwritten note or a personalized video follow-up using tools like Vidyard. Video follow-ups can increase open rates by 19% and click-through rates by 65%, making you stand out in a crowded inbox.